I have decided to start this page as there is lots of information about elephants on the internet. It is easy to find all the basic facts about elephants, how much they eat, how big they are, gestation period, what they eat, etc. BUT there is virtually no information about the reality of people living and working with elephants. There is alot of misinformation put out there by animal rights groups but their rhetoric doesnt look after or feed elephants everyday., WE DO, as do others that have elephants in their care.
FACT Tourism is good for elephants.
The last gainful employment for elephants was in the logging industry. With the ban on logging in the late 80's elephants were left with no way to earn a legal income. Of course some people continued to log illegally as they could not access alternative employment. This meant some elephants were fed amphetamines so they could work all night. Not good. The Kraal has bought elephants addicted to amphetamines and it is virtually impossible to get them off it if they have been on them a long time, so tragically some died, and others only lived a couple of years. Tourism is much easier work than logging. Every elephant in Thailand relies on tourism for an income.
Burmese statistics are very thorough about logging elephants and elephants log only live on average into their fifties. Our retired elephants are in their 60s and 70s, and our oldest is over 80 years old. By not logging for over 20 years their life span has increased. Tourism and now our Elephantstay program has actually prolonged their life as we have the income to buy the medicines and care they require if they get sick.
In addition one of the reasons elephant population has declined so drastically in the last 20 years is because they have not had the means to earn an income. There is no reason why people should not make money from elephants. People who do are no different from others who make money, people need money for food, housing, families, schooling, medical care etc, the people who own elephants have these needs as well. Without tourism the numbers of elephants would have declined even further. Look at Myanmar now, they are reducing logging to the point where elephants are in a precarious situation and their future is in jeopardy.
FACT Elephants love to paint.
Elephants love to paint because they get to do a fun activity with their mahouts. They get huge amounts of attention, positive reinforcement and treats from their mahout and so of course they are going to enjoy themselves. We only use younger elephants that are too young to give rides and it is amazing to watch how everyone plays together in between and physically and verbally show their love to those they associate with this activity.
FACT Giving tourist rides ensures successful births.
The Kraal has successfully bred 66 babies since February 2000. Nearly all the mothers gave rides to tourists up to the time they gave birth. Going into town and giving rides means the mothers get to socialise and exercise up to the time they give birth. This is obviously most important for their mental and physical well being. Elephants that do not work get bored, frustrated and physically out of condition. The success of our breeding program proves that giving rides to tourists is positive and enhances successful birth success rates. For more information about elephant riding please see Elephant riding facts.pdf
FACT Happy, healthy elephants breed.
Getting pregnant and having a successful birth for elephants is similar in principle to humans. If women are stressed they find it hard to get pregnant, the same can be said for elephants. So even though our elephants, as do all the elephants in Thailand, are sometimes chained and have mahouts who use a takaw, they still get pregnant and have healthy babies. Sixty six successful births since February 2000 is proof that happy, healthy elephants breed.
FACT Mahouts love their elephants and consider them part of their family
Whenever a baby elephant is born, the proud mahout considers the offspring as a new son or daughter. The mahout spends the vast majority of their time with their elephant. The mahout spends far less time with their wife or children, so the reality is the elephant is the closest living being to them. If they didnt love them how could they possibly spend the majority of their life with them? Especially when many other professions are more lucrative and an easier life style with jobs such as driving a tuk tuk or motorcycle taxi. If you ever experience looking after an elephant you will know how much work it is and how taxing it can be. Taking care of an elephant is a life not a job and it can only be done by those who love them and are prepared to make the necessary sacrifice and commitment.
FACT Mahouts and owners treat their elephants very well.
The majority of elephants are very well treated. One has to remember that the mahouts and the owners have invested a huge amount of time and money into these elephants and if they are not taken care of they will have nothing. It is not even logical to believe that people abuse their elephants to the extent many animal rights group would have one believe.
In the west the amount of money that is spent on rescuing all types of animals is astronomical. In Australia alone the RSPCA spends 80 million dollars a year, trying to protect animals. In Brisbane alone 1,000 cats and dogs are put down a week. If such a rich country has so many issues with animals, it is hardly surprising that there will be a percentage of people in a country like Thailand that dont take care of their elephant to the highest standard.
And of course mahouts are human and no human being is perfect. We get in bad moods or have a rotton day and I dont believe there is anyone out there who hasnt taken out their frustration on the person closest to them at some stage or another, whether it be their father, mother, sister, girlfriend, boyfriend, wife, husband etc. Mahouts are people like everyone else and yes, sometimes they might hit their elephant, every profession has their good and bad. We should all be striving to be the best we can and compassion and understanding can go a long way to helping and making improvements where there is need, criticism rarely if ever works.
FACT Not supporting domesticated elephants will ensure their extinction
There are only about 4,500 elephants left in Thailand. Most of these elephants live with people. There is barely enough jungle to support the wild populations that exist now, let alone any real increases. The reality is that elephants have a far greater chance of surviving into the future if the domestic populations are supported. Mahouts and owners need incentives to breed. If animal organisations paid money to elephant owners to breed and look after the mothers and babies then that would be a start. Without financial help, people can not be expected to bear a burden they cant possibly afford. Mahouts have families, to support as well as elephants and that requires money. The elephants are required to earn an income, if they are only costing the owner money then how will anyone survive?
FACT Putting elephants born in captivity back in the wild, generally means a death sentence.
Elephants, like any other domesticated or captive animal rely on people to feed them, take care of them and look after them when they are sick. To be put back into the jungle is impossible for the vast majority of elephants. Unless they have lived a large portion of their lives in the jungle.elephants have no idea how to survive.
FACT The process of seperating mothers and babies is about as traumatic as the first day of school for a child.
When a baby elephant is separated from its mother, there is naturally going to be some resistance. However many of us have witnessed the tears and tantrums of children on their first day of school. Elephants require training the same way children require schooling. They require patience love and understanding. They require sacrifice and commitment. As there are so few elephant left it is important to remember that elephants are continually going up in price. The Kraal bought a sick mother whose milk had run dry and her 6 month old baby and it cost 1.2 million baht. Fortunately the mother started producing milk again the very next day as the other mums reassured her that this was a good place and she would be well taken care of.
FACT Chaining elephants is not cruel.
Elephants that live with people need to be confined in some way. Elephant proof enclosures cost millions of dollars. Chains are a cheap and practical alternative that keeps the elephant and people safe. What most people dont realise is that elephant are incredibly strong and could break out of the chain if it really wanted to. However if the elephant is being cared for, ie fed, watered, bathed, excersised and being taken care of, it has no problem spending some of its time chained. After all, elephants in the wild, dont walk around looking at the scenery, they look for food and water.
FACT Using a takaw is necessary.
Thai people understand the world in symbolic terms. The elephant takaw is an instrument that has great meaning beyond its superficial use. It represents ancient teachings and has cultural significance that western values ignore. Too often western culture only sees the takaw in visual terms without any deeper historical or cultural meaning. There is no elephant culture in the west and there is no history of elephants living with people so it is difficult for western society to understand how the takaw is used and its significance to Thai elephant culture.
The takaw (bullhook or ankus as it is also known) is a much maligned and misunderstood instrument, probably because of its appearance. In elephant-keeping cultures where the takaw is standard, good mahouts very rarely use their takaws - or at least very rarely use them as it appears they must be used, in a slashing or stabbing motion. In fact, the takaw, so long as neither the weight nor the point of the head is used, is simply a light stick with a metal head shaped to a point. Even the point has a very subtle and gentle purpose; each mahout will have his takaw forged so that it ‘grabs’ elephant skin perfectly to his taste, allowing him to both extend his reach and to pull or tug into himself. The mahout, even afoot but especially mounted, is enabled to ‘signal’ otherwise unreachable control points on the elephant’s body. ‘Takaw commands’ are often more readable and able to convey nuance to the elephant than are either voice commands, feet commands, or ‘whole body commands’. Takaw commands can be used to augment a voice command, perhaps by modulating the speed or direction. At no time, in proper use, does the takaw break or bruise the skin.
It is undeniable, of course, that a larger pain-causing potential lurks in the takaw, a reserve should an elephant go truly out of control. In reality, while the potential for pain in a takaw is vital in medium-level confrontations between elephant and mahout, a takaw matters for little when an elephant really goes amok. A Thai mahout interviewed told of one day, at the request of a friend in need of some protection, sitting on the neck of a tusker of bad reputation while the friend inspected its front feet. The bull suddenly slammed the friend to the ground with his trunk and rapidly and repeatedly gored him. The man on the neck first tried to slam the point of the takaw into the auditory canal to puncture the elephant’s eardrum and when that failed, scrambling to stay on, he tried to stab into the right eye. But inside of fifteen seconds, the man on the ground was dead and the takaw had done not a bit of good.
In short, when used properly the takaw is a far more subtle and versatile tool than it appears, and in dire emergencies the takaw is a far less painful and powerful weapon than it appears. Hooks have been used to inflict needless wounds, but the cause is invariably poorly trained, poorly supervised, and poorly motivated mahouts rather than any cruelty intrinsic in the takaw. (If such men did not have takaws they would use machetes or whatever weapon lay close to hand.) The correctly used takaw is a conductor’s baton, not a policeman’s truncheon.
FACT Campaigns dont take care of, feed, or breed elephants.
Animal rights groups talk alot but they dont get up everyday and care and feed elephants. So how do they know what is good for an elephant. If the people put as much energy into doing real work, elephants might have a chance of surviving into the future. Campaign slogans such as 'set the elephants free' or 'animals have rights too' does not educate or get to the real issues which are complex, require real research and cant be put on a placard.
It is all very well to "rescue elephants from abuse" but are the number of elephants left so high that concentrating on a few heart wrenching cases is going to ensure that elephants do not become extinct? Trees can be planted, land bought, elephants bought off the streets or from camps, but does this mean they will breed? No it does not. Its a great way to get people to donate when they see sad pictures of poor elephants, but in reality it is only breeding more elephants that will ensure their survival. Unfortunately alot of the people who are really great at setting up charities, foundations, and raising money rarely concentrate on elephant breeding and how to do that successfully, because they can't. Everyone who comes to Elephantstay is helping to ensure the Asian elephant does not become extinct. By helping the old retired elephants you are ensuring that money other money can go to help the mothers and babies, the future is now and here.